« Previous  
 Next »

Kunin: Boys Can Cry

11/18/10 7:55AM By Madeleine M. Kunin
 MP3   Download MP3 

(HOST) As a former Vermont governor, commentator Madeleine Kunin takes the ups and downs of politics pretty much in stride, but one post-election event has got her feeling... downright emotional!

(KUNIN) When John Boehner cries, as he did at a press conference the morning after the election as the anticipated new Speaker of the House, he wins plaudits. So different from the time when Senator Muskie ran for President and was pilloried for shedding a tear in a snow storm in defense of his wife. But was it a tear or a snowflake? No matter, it made him look weak.

Boehner's tears were different. They revealed his humanity, showed he’s a good guy. A headline called  him "John the Weeper."  Critics went so far as to say what a pleasant contrast this was to the "steely" Nancy Pelosi.  No show of emotion, what a pity.

What if Nancy Pelosi had cried when she was firstbecame Speaker of the House?  We know the answer; she would have been toast.  An emotional woman, third in line for the Presidency? No way.

If there was ever a question whether gender stereotypes still exist, that question was answered in the post election press coverage of the out-going and incoming Speakers.

Remember when Hillary Clinton had a "welling up of tears" moment the day before the New Hampshire Primary in 2008?  The media went wild. Can she be Commander in Chief, John Edwards questioned. Others commented that at last the Ice Maiden had melted. Or, was it ploy to gain sympathy?

Women in leadership cannot cry without raising a storm of commentary. When I held a press conference to announce that I would not be seeking fourth term as Governor, it was an emotional moment for me. Was I doing the right thing by leaving my position, voluntarily?  As I stood at the top of the stairs, waiting to go down to the first floor of the Vermont State House where the press was gathered, I told my self, "Don’t cry, whatever you do, don’t cry."

I got through it without a tear, until the very end when I looked at my weepy staff.  I reached for a handkerchief, just in case.  That’s when the camera flash went off. That was the photo they used.  I hated it.

I realize now that when women and men can shed an equal quantity of tears in public, that’s when we’ll have equal power.

(TAG) You can find more commentaries by Madeleine Kunin at VPR-dot-net.
comments powered by Disqus
Supported By
Become an Underwriter | Find an Underwiter